A Guide to Discontinuity

The categories in the Discontinuity Guide should be fairly easy to understand, but here's an explanation anyway.

Roots: Doctor Who author Ben Aaronovitch once wrote "Talent borrows, genius steals, and Doctor Who authors get it wholesale off the back of a lorry." Though that may not be entirely true, this section mentions the texts that have, or might have, influenced a story - hopefully including several less obvious ones. For some stories noting every minor quote or derivative reference can get overwhelming. For example, I have a page-by-page guide to references in the novel The Hollow Men written by co-author Keith Topping. Said guide totals 92 pages. In such cases, we simply present the highlights.

Goofs: Accidental cock-ups, intentional aspects that just don't work, and (especially) gaping holes in the plot.

Fashion Victims: Ridiculous clothing.

Fluffs: Whilst it was common in the Classic Series for actors to fluff their lines onscreen changes in recording techniques mean that rarely happens now. However, sometimes stories will intentionally include fluffs.

Technobabble: Doctor Who is often science fiction. Which frequently means made-up science and technology. This section lists it in more detail than you wanted to know.

Double Entendres: Phrases that have more than one meaning. Sometimes we've taken dialogue or narration out of context for humour value.

Dialogue Disasters: Even the best stories can contain some truly cringe-worthy dialogue. Here it is, in all its toe-curling nastiness.

Dialogue Triumphs: Even the worst stories sometimes contain dialogue that sparkles. Here is the brightest and best.

Memorable Moments: Sometimes it's the events that stand out the most. Here are the crowning moments of awesome and crowning moments of funny.

Continuity: The meat of the guide, this is the collection of fictional facts revealed in the story. Except when those facts fit into the categories below:

Links: References to other stories.

Extras: Sometimes a story comes with bonus material. This tells you all about it with links where it's online. DVD extras are not listed here.

Location: Where and when the story takes place.

Future History: Facts about the future (defined here as anything that happens after the publication date of the story).

Unrecorded Adventures: References to stories that we haven't seen yet. If a later author tells that story, it will still be listed here. Unless it was a deliberate reference to another story that was in the pipeline whilst this one was being written.

Boxed Sections and Q.v. Sometimes we use a boxed section to go into an issue in depth, especially if it affects several stories. The Q.v. section contains a link to any boxed sections that are relevant to this story.

The Bottom Line: Is the story any good? When we disagree this is separated out into Prosecution and Defence so you can see both sides.

Feel free to Contact Us if you have any questions about the site, or any technical problems with it. You may also want to check out our Privacy Policy. There is also an About Us page, if you really want to read one.

Add new comment


  • Allowed HTML tags: <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.